Written byMy uncle thought he’d scored the deal of a lifetime a few years ago when he purchased a used 2005 Honda Pilot. It appeared to be in excellent condition, drove well in a test spin, and fit the whole family. But soon, he was back and forth to the repair shop for a bad transmission and misfiring ignition coils. Terror turned to frustration — and thousands in repair bills — in a matter of moments.
That is the Honda Pilot, after all. Though renowned as a reliable, family-friendly midsize SUV, certain model years come with hidden problems that could find you shelling out significantly more than you’d hoped for. In this article, you’ll find the Honda Pilot years to avoid, learn more about typical problems for each model year, and help you determine the best version for you, one with comfort and confidence.
Must Check: Chevy Equinox Years to Avoid Are These Models a Risky Buy
Why Do Some Honda Pilot Years Fall Short?
Honda has a strong reputation for producing durable and reliable vehicles. But even the best automakers have their off years. Whether due to the haste of rushing redesigns to market, supplier failures, or simply poor engineering decisions, some Pilots have suffered major issues that have affected the performance, safety, and owner satisfaction of the vehicle.
There are specific issues I always see bad year trend:
- Transmission failures
- Engine misfires
- Excessive oil consumption
- Electrical system glitches
- Brake wear and VCM failings
- Years to Avoid Honda Pilot (Details Thereof)
Honda Pilot Years to Avoid (With Details)
We’ll also dive into the worst years for the Honda Pilot, what happened, and why you should steer clear of those model years.
1. 2003 Honda Pilot – Started Rocky
Common Issues:
- Transmission failure
- Torque converter breakdowns
- Premature engine wear
“I’ve replaced the Transmission at 90,000 miles. Honda would not cover it even though the car had been well maintained.” – Greg H., Florida
Why to Avoid: The initial Pilot year suffered from some serious drivetrain issues. Unless – steer clear, unless it’s been rebuilt with evidence.
2. 2004 Honda Pilot – Transmission Problems
Common Issues:
- Repeated Transmission slipping
- Shuddering during acceleration
- Faulty EGR valves
It now suffers from the same 4-speed automatic transmission issues inherited from 2003, and it has yet to see significant improvements.
Why to Avoid: Same severe transmission woes, just slightly less often than the 2003 year, but it is still a pain.
3. 2005 Honda Pilot – Electrical Gremlins Emerge
Common Issues:
- PCM (Powertrain Control Module) failures
- Engine misfiring
- Ignition coil problems
“The car was great until the engine light began coming on every week. – Tina B., Arizona
Why to Avoid: Due to issues with electronics and engine performance, this model year is a poor choice for long-term ownership.
4. 2009 Honda Pilot – New Look, Old Problems
Common Issues:
- Excessive oil consumption
- Weak acceleration
- In-car entertainment and climate control problems
Having restyled the Pilot in 2009 with a boxer look and updated technology, Honda provided many owners with what they felt was an unattractive vehicle and electrical trouble.
Why to Avoid: All style and no substance. Too many fucking mechanical and tech issues.
5. 2011 Honda Pilot – The Brake Burner
Common Issues:
- Premature brake wear
- Engine misfiring
- VCM-related issues
“Brakes were worn out every 20,000 miles. I eventually had to go with non-OEM pads.” – Rachel C., New Jersey.
Why to Avoid: With all those brake replacements and engine problems, this one’s too expensive long-term.
6. 2013 Honda Pilot – Behind the Times
Common Issues:
- Unresponsive Transmission
- Poor fuel economy
- Outdated infotainment
This model seems outdated compared to its rivals, and customer service is certainly not excellent either — I made the mistake of calling customer service before reading the reviews.
Why to Avoid: No lemon, but lagging rivals in refinement and efficiency.
7. 2016 Honda Pilot – Too Many Glitches
Common Issues:
- Jerky 9-speed Automatic Transmission
- Infotainment freezing
- Rearview camera malfunctions
Honda introduced modern technology in 2016, although early bugs contributed to a painful ownership experience for many.
“Amazing features, but the gear shifts are so hard, it feels like something is breaking.” – Luis R., North Carolina.
Why to Avoid: A bit too tech-forward and not quite bug-free. Reliability suffered as a result.
8. 2017 Honda Pilot – Recalls and Rattles
Common Issues:
- Fuel injector failure
- Knocking noises in the suspension
- Problems with remote start and keyless systems
Honda has recalled its vehicles multiple times this year, most often due to issues with fuel delivery systems.
Why to Avoid: Stronger result than 2016, though plagued by mechanical and software gremlins.
9. 2020 Honda Pilot – Fancy but Flawed
Common Issues:
- Transmission hesitation
- Battery drainage
- Lane assist malfunctions
Honda included a suite of driver-assist features and a slimmer body, but complaints of false collision alerts and electrical drain spread.
Why Avoid: It’s still a solid overall SUV, but a truckload of annoying electrical and driver-assist system gremlins weigh it down.
Read More:
- Dodge Journey Years to Avoid Some Are Real Headaches
- Mazda CX5 Years to Avoid and the Worst Problems They Have
- Toyota Tundra Years to Avoid and the Worst Problems Owners Faced
Quick Reference Table: Worst Honda Pilot Years
| Model Year | Major Problems | Why to Avoid |
| 2003 | Transmission failure | Expensive repairs, early breakdowns |
| 2004 | Same transmission issues | No major fixes from 2003 |
| 2005 | PCM and ignition coil failure | Unreliable engine performance |
| 2009 | Oil consumption, HVAC failures | Poor refinement, costly upkeep |
| 2011 | Brake wear, engine misfires | Constant repairs and maintenance |
| 2013 | Outdated tech, poor MPG | Low value compared to peers |
| 2016 | Transmission, infotainment issues | Too many tech bugs |
| 2017 | Fuel injector failures | Multiple recalls and reliability concerns |
| 2020 | Driver-assist faults, battery drain | Feature overload with poor execution |
Best Honda Pilot Model Years to Buy
While some Pilots fall short, others have proven their reliability and value. Here are the most recommended years:
| Model Year | Why It’s Good |
| 2008 | Fewer complaints, solid drivetrain |
| 2015 | Refined final year of 2nd generation |
| 2018 | Improved 9-speed transmission, better tech |
| 2021–2023 | Modern features, strong J.D. Power reliability scores |
How Honda Reacted to the Complaints
Honda has published service bulletins and recalls and occasionally offers extended warranties on known problems. For example:
- The transmission failures on early models were rectified through a redesign in 2006.
- VCM problems led to software updates that provided better engine control.
- The 2016–2017 infotainment issues were mitigated through firmware updates performed at dealerships.
Many owners still had to rely on their pocketbooks — so don’t depend solely on Honda’s fixes. Always check recall records.
Used Pilot Buying Tips: Account for Parts
Check the VIN History: Several services are available ([NHTSA] and Carfax) to check for recalls and accident reports.
Request Maintenance Records: Pass on any Pilots without maintenance records.
Check the Transmission: Stand outside the vehicle and shift from park to drive and reverse; there should be no hesitation, rough shifts, or signs of leaks.
Test the Infotainment and Cameras: Press every button before purchasing to ensure optimal functionality.
Avoid Budget Temptation: That lender role is all the more critical if a beat-up 2003 or 2005 model carries a price that’s too good to be true — because repair costs could get astronomical.
Conclusion: The Right Pilot Is Worth the Wait
The Honda Pilot is a spacious vehicle with a lot to offer, but you’ll only get the space, comfort, and family-friendly features if you choose the right model year. As we’ve reported, certain model years are fraught with mechanical, electrical, and software problems that can turn a dream SUV into a money pit.
If you’re in the market for a used Honda Pilot, stay away from the problematic years (such as) 2003, 2005, 2016, and 2020. Instead, focus on the reliable ones, such as those from 2015, 2018, or newer, which come with fewer headaches and better technology. A bit of research now could save thousands later.
When in doubt, have a pre-purchase inspection, run a VIN check, and always take it for a test drive. This way, you’ll have all the fun the Pilot offers—and none of the jarring disappointments.
